Tesla’s Musk Says Roadster Kicks Ferrari’s Ass; Is He Right?

“This kicks the ass of any Ferrari except the Enzo.” — Tesla Motors CEO Elon Musk regarding the Tesla Roadster.

We took a good long look at Tesla’s SEC filing and IPO road show presentation on Monday, and there was a lot to cover. One detail we skipped was this quote from Tesla’s commander-in-chief Musk, a man known for his over-the-top statements. He and Tesla have made a lot of bold claims about their company and their product, but this just might be the boldest.

Musk says his Roadster can go toe-to-toe with any Ferrari that isn’t an Enzo. Can it? We dug through our test numbers and pulled out the top-shelf Tesla Roadster Sport and seven Ferraris we’ve tested to find out. Unfortunately, we only have partial numbers on some of the cars, because getting a free Ferrari to flog on the track is difficult for even us. For comparison’s sake, we even threw in the mighty Enzo itself.

Take a look at what we measured for all the cars and tell us what you think of Musk’s proclamation.

2010 Tesla Roadster Sport

0-60: 3.7 secs
1/4 Mile: 12.6 secs @ 102.6 mph
60-0 Braking: 113 ft
200-ft Skid Pad: 0.98 g (avg)
MT Figure Eight: 24.6 secs @ 0.81 g (avg)
Power: 288 horsepower/295 pound-feet
Base Price: $130,450 (with $7500 Federal tax credit)

 image

2008 Ferrari F430

0-60: 4.2 secs
1/4 Mile: 12.3 secs @ 120.7 mph
60-0 Braking: 107 ft
200-ft Skid Pad: 0.95 g (avg)
MT Figure Eight: 24.6 secs @0.80 g (avg)
Power: 483 horsepower/343 pound-feet
Base Price: $191,775

 image

2008 Ferrari F430 Scuderia

0-60: 3.1 secs
1/4 Mile: 11.2 secs @ 126.7 mph
60-0 Braking: 93 ft
Power: 503 horsepower/347 pound-feet
Base Price: $272,306

 image

2008 Ferrari 599 GTB Fiorano

0-60: 3.2 secs
1/4 Mile: 11.3 secs @ 126.4 mph
60-0 Braking: 104 ft
200-ft Skid Pad: 0.95 g (avg)
MT Figure Eight: 25.0 secs @0.79 g (avg)
Power: 612 horsepower/448 pound-feet
Base Price: $317,595

 image

2010 Ferrari 16M Scuderia Spider

0-60: 3.8 secs (sub-optimal surface)
1/4 Mile: 11.8 secs @ 122.7 mph (sub-optimal surface)
60-0 Braking: 96 ft
Power: 503 horsepower/347 pound-feet
Base Price: $313,350

 image

2010 Ferrari California

0-60: 3.5 secs
1/4 Mile: 11.9 secs @ 117.4 mph
60-0 Braking: 100 ft
200-ft Skid Pad: 0.99 g (avg)
Power: 454 horsepower/357 pound-feet
Base Price: $192,000

 image

2011 Ferrari 599 GTO

0-60: 3.4 secs (mfr)
Power: 661 horsepower/457 pound-feet
Base Price: $450,000 (est)

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia

0-60: 3.4 secs (mfr)
Power: 557 horsepower/398 pound-feet
Base Price: $213,500 (est)

 image

By Scott Evans